Grand Canal Dock, Uber and the Tech Bubble – David McWilliams Urges Learn from History

– Uber, Grand Canal Dock, Canals, the New Tech Bubble and the Financial Mania of Today
– “Both the canal and railway manias led to ridiculously overvalued companies, whose subsequent crash brought financial ruin to many”
– “Yet these technologies did change the world, eventually”
– Time to learn the lessons of history

by David McWilliams

Last week Uber, the taxi-sharing app, floated on the New York stock exchange. As a result the company is now worth just over $65 billion.

Nasdaq Bubble 2019 (1990 to Today – Macrotrends.net)

We are entering the 11th year of a bull market, and because success tends to breed a disregard for the possibility of failure, investors expressed “disappointment” at the shares’ performance in the first few days of trading.

Does this tell us where we might be in the global economic and financial cycle? Tech insiders are said to be “disappointed” at this valuation of more than $60 billion for a taxi firm with precious few assets, that has no immediate prospect of making a profit, and burns through $2 billion of shareholders’ money a year.

Think about this for a minute: a company that loses money, has no real prospect of profits, and spends shareholders’ money in an extraordinarily cavalier way has a higher value than thousands of solid companies that have been making more money for decades.

Maybe it is very 20th century of me, but surely profit is what shareholders should be concerned about? Is this the essence of financial mania?

Coincidentally, I was considering this mania for tech and so-called tech stocks as the Dart was delayed at Grand Canal Dock in Dublin one morning.

Grand Canal Dock (Flickr)

Grand Canal Dock is positioned at the mouth of the Grand Canal, the result of a mania for canals in the late 18th century, and the Dart is the descendent of the first railway built in Ireland, itself the result of a speculative mania for railways in the mid-19th century.

In both episodes great fortunes were made and lost in speculation on the shares of companies that didn’t make profits but augured riches betting on the new technologies of the times, burning through shareholders’ funds to get to the promised land.

It seems that speculative mania is part of human nature, and exciting new technologies have a way of bringing out our manic speculative side.

Creative destruction

Joseph Schumpeter, a great Austrian economist, believed that the capitalist economy was “in the perennial gale of creative destruction” where industries and ways of doing things were constantly swept away by new technologies.

Innovation, therefore, is the key to capitalism. It is the outstanding fact of economic history. And where innovation drives the economy, the speculator is rarely far behind.

When the innovation becomes more established and begins to generate a steady return, the speculator is overtaken by the investor, who wants a stream of income more than a quick capital gain.

In essence, the investor is concerned with the present, with stability and with a regular flow of income, while the speculator is driven by the future and the promise of one-off riches or hitting the jackpot. Novelties and inventions have always tickled the speculator.

In the late 18th century, Britain and Ireland went through a canal mania. Canals were the future as they promised to link cities and countryside together.

In the more distant past natural rivers had the power to dictate to contours of the economy. Large parts of the country could be connected like never before, opening up opportunities for trade and linking inland cities and agricultural heartlands with the ports for exports and imports.

Between 1770 and 1800 more than 1,000 miles of canals were built. Initially shares in canal companies soared, huge profits were made, and far-reaching claims about the social impact of canals were suggested, indicating that canals would dramatically alter the social fabric, liberating people to mix and travel cheaply to places once deemed inaccessible.

In the 1790s, the speculation reached mania proportion. Fifty new canals were initiated, and informal meetings of canal speculators, known as “navigational offices”, sprang up all over Dublin as well as many cities in England. The term “Irish Navvies” – so long associated with Irish workers in England – came from the name for the Irish migrants who dug the canals in England.

French revolution

The canal mania came to an abrupt end in 1793 following the recession after the shock of the French revolution and the Terror. Canal shares collapsed.

The Grand Canal linking Ringsend, Dublin, to the Shannon was not completed until 1804, bringing ruin to many speculators who never saw a return on their investment.

The “gale of creative destruction” is relentless, and the logic of canals was blown away by the arrival of steam railways in the late 1820s. Again the speculators had a ball; the shiny new technology attracted them once more.

This time railway shares soared. The Dublin-Kingstown line, essentially the first Dart, was completed in 1834, financed by shares issued to speculators.

There was a wobble in the market in the late 1830s when interest rates rose, but in the 1840s, while the famine raged in the west of Ireland, the monied classes of not just Dublin but all of Ireland immersed themselves in an extraordinary bout of railway share mania.

Enormous amounts of money were speculated on the promise of riches, debts were incurred and – like the property bubble here not so long ago – massive debts built up. All the while low interests rate encouraged speculation.

When the crash came, following the revolutionary year of 1848, the speculators, who misdiagnosed speculation with investment, were destroyed. A few years later the body of Irish Liberal MP John Sadlier was found on Hampstead Heath, London, dead by his own hand. He and his associates based in Tipperary and Carlow had been up to their necks in railway speculation. He personally owed Bank of Ireland £400,000.

Overvalued companies

Both the canal and railway manias led to ridiculously overvalued companies, whose subsequent crash brought financial ruin to many. And yet these technologies did change the world, eventually.

The likes of Uber may well change the world by disruption in an act of Schumpterian creative destruction. But that doesn’t mean that the rewards will go to Uber or its shareholders.

In fact last week’s flotation is aimed at giving the impression that ownership of the company has moved from the early speculator to the more cautious investor. However, given that it hasn’t any profits yet, that might be premature.

As the Dart resumes its journey south, on a route laid down in the first railway mania, we pass the Grand Canal’s original grain stores, soon to be gyms for tech employees.

The lessons of history for Uber reverberate.

by David McWilliams on David McWilliams.ie


Gold Prices Build On Weekly Gain – Indian Demand, Falling Stocks, Terrorism, Trade Wars, Economic and Political Uncertainty Supporting Gold

Gold prices have consolidated on last week’s slight gains with a myriad of factors supporting prices.

Gold had a 0.6% gain last week, with strong gains on Thursday in particular, while very undervalued silver gained 1.2% for the week.

Spot gold was 0.2% higher to $1,286 per ounce. In late trading in Asia, the precious metal touched $1,287.32 which is it’s highest level since May 17.

Gold is building on last week’s gain and the one-week high is due to robust Indian demand, stocks falling due to fears of a protracted U.S.-China trade war and poor economic data from the U.S., EU and globally.


WATCH VIDEO HERE

News and Commentary

Gold falls, but tallies a weekly gain after reasserting haven role

Gold firms above $1,280 as weak U.S. data rekindles rate-cut hopes

India gold prices flip to premium as demand picks up

Terror fears as ‘parcel bomb’ explosion injures 13 in Lyon, France

Dow heads for fifth straight negative week, longest losing streak since 2011

Weak U.S. manufacturing underscores slowing economic growth

Irish property market at risk of new boom to bust cycle, OECD warns  

Russia’s Central Bank to Consider Gold-Backed Cryptocurrencies for Mutual Settlements

Australian finds A$100,000 gold nugget using metal detector

The Fed has spooked markets with an ice-cold warning

Exploding bonds, a dipping euro, economic turmoil: what the election results could mean for Europe

Grand Canal Dock and a story of manic speculation

LBMA Gold Prices (USD, GBP & EUR – AM/ PM Fix)
24-May-19 1281.50 1282.50, 1011.36 1011.89 & 1145.92 1145.40
23-May-19 1275.95 1283.65, 1009.79 1015.37 & 1146.19 1152.46
22-May-19 1274.00 1273.80, 1005.44 1008.09 & 1141.12 1141.20
21-May-19 1276.00 1271.15, 1004.85 998.62 & 1144.19 1139.84
20-May-19 1275.25 1276.85, 1000.05 1003.22 & 1142.63 1143.42
17-May-19 1285.80 1280.80, 1007.55 1005.17 & 1152.08 1146.70
16-May-19 1295.55 1291.70, 1009.62 1009.46 & 1155.76 1154.78
15-May-19 1298.90 1299.10, 1005.87 1011.87 & 1158.75 1161.53
14-May-19 1297.60 1298.40, 1002.14 1005.48 & 1154.34 1158.04
13-May-19 1282.95 1295.60, 985.95 994.89 & 1142.47 1151.27

Mark O'Byrne

Also on news-goldcore-com

Videos

Tavi Costa- The Fed is Trapped

Silver Market Predictions – Ed Steer Talks about the Silver & Gold Price

Are We In A Financial Bubble? Peter Grandich Interview

Blog posts

Lawrence Lepard – Living in a World with Inflation

Lawrence Lepard Portfolio Manager and advocate of sound money, is our guest on this episode of GoldCore TV. With 40% of money in the US being created in the last 2 years, we ask Lawrence if the Fed is trapped. If so will this mean that it is going to be very difficult for them […]

READ MORE

Supply Chain Crisis Effects on Gold & Silver

The broken chain – could the supply crunch be worse than the oil crunch of the 1970s Anyone that has bought a new or used car in the last year has faced higher prices and long wait times for delivery. This is all because of the very small but essential semiconductor, which is in short […]

READ MORE

This is a Long Term Bullish Pattern for Gold – Gareth Soloway on GoldCore TV

“This is a long term bullish pattern for gold!” – Gareth Soloway Gold In this latest episode of GoldCore TV, Gareth Soloway joins Dave Russell to discuss what what the charts are suggesting for the stock markets, bond markets and #bitcoin. In addition to this he also takes a look at his gold price forecast 2021 and beyond.Gareth identifies the key levels that […]

READ MORE

Featured

Gold, the Tried-and-True Inflation Hedge for What’s Coming!

READ MORE

How High is Too High for Rising Government Bond Yields?

READ MORE

Silver – 7 Reasons it is Still Set to Soar

READ MORE
Newsletter
Category
Archives
Popular

No posts available

Videos

Tavi Costa- The Fed is Trapped

Silver Market Predictions – Ed Steer Talks about the Silver & Gold Price

Are We In A Financial Bubble? Peter Grandich Interview

Blog posts

Lawrence Lepard – Living in a World with Inflation

Lawrence Lepard Portfolio Manager and advocate of sound money, is our guest on this episode of GoldCore TV. With 40% of money in the US being created in the last 2 years, we ask Lawrence if the Fed is trapped. If so will this mean that it is going to be very difficult for them […]

READ MORE

Supply Chain Crisis Effects on Gold & Silver

The broken chain – could the supply crunch be worse than the oil crunch of the 1970s Anyone that has bought a new or used car in the last year has faced higher prices and long wait times for delivery. This is all because of the very small but essential semiconductor, which is in short […]

READ MORE

This is a Long Term Bullish Pattern for Gold – Gareth Soloway on GoldCore TV

“This is a long term bullish pattern for gold!” – Gareth Soloway Gold In this latest episode of GoldCore TV, Gareth Soloway joins Dave Russell to discuss what what the charts are suggesting for the stock markets, bond markets and #bitcoin. In addition to this he also takes a look at his gold price forecast 2021 and beyond.Gareth identifies the key levels that […]

READ MORE

Featured

Gold, the Tried-and-True Inflation Hedge for What’s Coming!

READ MORE

How High is Too High for Rising Government Bond Yields?

READ MORE

Silver – 7 Reasons it is Still Set to Soar

READ MORE