The facts of gold confiscation: The saga continues…
This is the second in a series of posts looking at the confiscation experience of the 1930s.
In our post Gold Confiscation: Will History Repeat Itself?
On March 31 we looked at the gold confiscation experience in America during the 1930s.
To recap we mentioned that then gold was official money according to the government. Also, the government needed gold inside the banking system to relaunch banks following the years of the Great Depression.
Since gold is not government sanctioned money today governments do not have the same need to call in physical metals.
Importantly last week we also mentioned that no gold was stolen. Banks and governments paid for every ounce of gold.
This week we expand on further threads of the confiscation story.
Firstly -Why were some gold coins not called in while most were?
And second, if a government did want to call in gold during the decade of the 2020s, could it even be accomplished? If so, how?
Numismatic Gold Coins Exemption
Turning to the first question of why some gold coins were exempt from the Executive Order to turn in gold to banks; Numismatic gold coins were exempt because they were considered objects of art or history. However, not functioning as money during the 1930s.
As with wedding rings numismatic gold coins were not considered vital gold for relaunching America’s banking sector after the depression of the 1930s.
The distinction between numismatic gold coins that were exempted from President Roosevelt’s Executive Order for gold versus general circulation gold coins can be slightly complex.
An example of a numismatic coin that would be exempt is the oldest known gold coin in existence which was found in 2014 by a scuba diver off Bulgaria’s Black Sea coast. Read more on the accidental discovery of this coin here.
Since this coin is both extremely rare and artfully beautiful it would have been considered numismatic and exempt from the 1933 Executive Order.
Being 2,700 years old and being literally one of a kind makes clear that such a coin would not have been turned into a bank.
Nor would any government agent be rightful in asking for this coin.
In fact, the President, or any government agent, who tried confiscating this coin would have intense dramatic unanswerable questions put to it by political opponents and the free press.
Politicians during the crisis will attack the large middle section of any solution while exempting the difficult problems of special cases found in small amounts.
Thus, Roosevelt’s Executive order called for the general circulation of coins and gold bars to be turned in. However, avoided battling over such items as historically significant or exceptionally emotional items like wedding rings and art.
No gold leaf picture frames were called in by Roosevelt the Executive order.
And yes, President Trump’s golden toilet in Manhattan would have been safe Roosevelt under the exemption.
So a single 2,700-year-old historic gold coin is numismatic. But what about a single gold coin purchased in 2020 from a dealer selling part of a 10,000-coin production run of collectible coins?
Nope probably not numismatic.
Not if Roosevelt’s litmus test from the 1933 Executive Order was applied on an art basis alone.
Keep in mind that the Roosevelt litmus test of whether a coin was exempt did not care what premium was paid for the gold coin above its ounce value.
Gold Confiscation: Can it Happen Today?
Now to the second point – could governments even carry out a confiscation today?
The confiscation will not happen again. This is because bank bailouts by the government are now preplanned using living wills and contingent capital bonds.
But if we were today to make an ideological assumption that confiscation was possible for some reason, how could it be done?
As mentioned above governments like to avoid complaints from citizens and the media.
Therefore, it seems to us that the easiest place for government to get its hands on large amounts of gold are the futures market and the exchange traded fund market.
Any 2022 government trying to call in silver and gold would be smart to padlock the doors of LBMA and CME warehouses.
There are close to 10,000 tonnes in these warehouses of gold owned not by small investors but by giant investment banks.
The hue and cry would be minimal since investment banks and government work together frequently already. Futures markets for gold did not exist in the 1930s.
If they had you can be sure Roosevelt would have started [and finished?] there instead of inviting discord from individual citizens.
Another important pot of gold exists today which did not exist in the 1930s.
Exchange Traded Funds [or ETFs] began in 2003 when the World Gold Council sponsored the very first one.
Today the dozen or so ETFs in existence collectively own more than 3,200 tonnes of gold.
ETFs hold more than 27,000 tonnes of silver.
The title to this gold rests not with individual investors but with corporate trusts controlled by lawyers and bankers.
Certainly, Roosevelt would have claimed this ETF gold into the financial system during 1933 before bothering to call in coins and bars from individuals.
Confiscation as a historical event is worthy of study.
But we have shown it is not a worthy reason to fear the government stealing physical gold and silver held by individuals in this century.
From The Trading Desk
The Gold price this week has stayed above the crucial $1,900 level and continued within a narrow trading range between $1,917 and $1,945.
Gold is holding these levels on the back of the stronger USD and the continued strength in US Treasuries which generally have a negative correlation with the price of Gold.
Also of note last week we saw the yield curve temporarily invert, closely watched, and generally signals a recession flag, not generally imminent but the warning shot has been fired.
The Fed minutes from the March meeting were released yesterday.
We got a more hawkish fed with officials discussing the pace of interest rate hikes ahead.
Many participants noted that one or more 50 basis point increases may be needed at future meetings, particularly if inflation pressures remain elevated.
They also noted the Fed would start to reduce the central bank balance sheet by $95 billion per month.
The Fed more than doubled in holdings during the pandemic with its monthly bond purchases which only came to an end last month, even though we had roaring inflation which the Fed had initially described as transitory.
Have the Fed made a huge policy error here and left it all too late with these necessary responses, will it tip the US into a recession?
Silver Britannia offer UK – We have just taken delivery of 10,000 Silver Britannia’s at our London depository.
Available for storage in London or immediate delivery within the UK.
These are available at the lowest premium in the market (which includes VAT at 20%).
Purchase these online or contact our trading desk for more information.
Excellent stock and availability on all Gold Coins and bars. Please contact our trading desk with any questions you may have.
Silver coins are now available for delivery or storage in Ireland and the EU with the lowest premium in the market.
Starting as low as Spot plus 37% for Silver Britannia’s 100oz and 1000oz bars are also available VAT free in Zurich starting at 8% for the 1000oz bars and 12.5% for the 100oz bars.
Please see below our extended trading hours.
** We have extended our opening hours. Phone lines, online ordering and WebChat are now open until 09:00-22:00 (Europe/Dublin) USA 09:00 to 17:00 EST**
GOLD PRICES (USD, GBP & EUR – AM/ PM LBMA Fix)
06-04-2022 1929.00 1930.15 1472.41 1475.99 1768.31 1768.98
05-04-2022 1929.45 1944.05 1468.70 1477.09 1756.57 1772.58
04-04-2022 1927.10 1930.30 1469.03 1471.85 1748.46 1756.57
01-04-2022 1933.35 1929.40 1472.44 1472.90 1748.72 1746.49
31-03-2022 1924.10 1942.15 1466.93 1479.53 1729.77 1751.63
30-03-2022 1917.80 1933.85 1458.30 1468.57 1719.12 1732.73
29-03-2022 1911.05 1910.00 1460.23 1453.89 1733.51 1717.09
28-03-2022 1927.00 1937.05 1467.41 1481.26 1754.34 1766.40
25-03-2022 1956.65 1953.80 1484.90 1479.61 1777.81 1773.66
24-03-2022 1945.90 1965.20 1475.58 1489.62 1771.55 1787.55
Buy gold coins and bars and store them in the safest vaults in Switzerland, London or Singapore with GoldCore.
Learn why Switzerland remains a safe-haven jurisdiction for owning precious metals. Access Our Most Popular Guide, the Essential Guide to Storing Gold in Switzerland here